Allison Tant moving, slightly, in the right direction.

FDP_130109A few days ago, Florida Democratic Party Chair Allison Tant finally admitted that her team lost. After an election night filled with congratulatory tweets, Tant said in a radio interview with WFSU in Tallahassee that she takes responsibility.

“Do I take responsibility for this outcome? Of course”, Tant told WFSU.

However, it is the rest of her interview that deserves a second look. Here is the rest of Tant’s statement, according the WFSU:

“Well, obviously we got beat. We got beat across the nation. We got beat in Florida. But, I’m proud of the race we ran. I mean, do I want a different outcome. Yes! Do I take a responsibility for this outcome? Of course! I mean, we built a really good machine. We built a really good race car and we’re going to keep it going. We’re going to deep dive into what happened and who didn’t show up to vote and take corrective measures.”

Of course, the first comment that deserves attention is that “we got beat across the nation”. As I mentioned last week, the Florida Democrats would more than likely use the “national wave” as a reason for failure, though the wave cannot explain the Saunders loss and Graham win. Still, even though Tant does mention “the wave”, she also takes responsibility in her statement, which is more important. Therefore, it seems Tant has employed a “buck stops here” approach to this manner, even if she feels that the race was a “wave” and beyond her control.

Even though Tant took responsibility, it is the second part of that statement that is troublesome for Florida Democrats. Tant says “I mean, we built a really good machine. We built a really good race car and we’re going to keep going”. As someone who is a racing enthusiast and has actually raced at Sebring, a race car that finishes dead last is not a good race car. And the fact that the main components of the race car, such has the engine and transmission, failed miserably and have a history of failing is also not a good sign. In the case of the Florida Democratic Party, Allison Tant is the chassis, which holds all of the bits of the car together, but the engine is Scott Arceneaux and the transmission is Christian Ulvert. And, as a race car driver, or even an everyday car owner, can tell you, once the engine and transmission fails, they need to be replace, without exception. However, the chassis can remain.

As I said in my earlier article about this subject, I think removing Allison Tant from the Florida Democratic Party chair position is not productive, especially now that she has admitted that the buck stops at her door. If you are a race car team and you have an engine and gearbox that fails, you do not throw out the entire car, but you replace the bad components. That is what Allison Tant needs to do. Also, there is some problem with the electrical components that Tant might want to look at as well (ie…the communications team).

Rebuilding the Florida Democratic Party is important for there to be a vibrant two-party system in what is considered a “purple state” nationally. But rebuilding the party, and looking at the issue in a systemic way, is the most productive way to go about this change. Unfortunately, the Nan Rich supporters have made this an issue about the Rich-Crist primary. The rebuilding of the FDP has nothing to do with Nan Rich, nothing the do with the gubernatorial primary, and is just an excuse to continue complaining about an issue that was settled months ago. People need to move on.

While Allison Tant said the buck stops at her door, her next moves are vital to the success or failure of the Florida Democratic Party. If she keeps the same top staffers, the Florida Democratic Party is doomed to fail yet again. Not only will the party be unable to operate, but rank-and-file Democrats, who provide the local blood, sweat and tears for Democratic candidates, will lose faith in the Florida Democratic Party. As a result, the central Democratic Party apparatus will be weak, and individual candidates will have to not only fend for themselves, but form unorganized coalitions for electoral support. Therefore, the Florida Democratic Party needs to regain credibility with the party faithful with a strong, centralized party.

As for the aforementioned staffers for the party, Arceneaux and Ulvert, the pressure for them to be relieve of their duties is increasing daily. Of course, those who have been vocal about Tant in the past have mentioned that these two individuals should be removed. But even allies of Allison Tant, such as Kartik Krishnaiyer’s website The Florida Squeeze, are offering poll questions regarding Arceneaux’s and Ulvert’s future. Once Tant allies are asking this question, the answer should be obvious to the Florida Democratic Party chair.


7 thoughts on “Allison Tant moving, slightly, in the right direction.

  1. As a resident of a small North Florida County and a DEC member it has been clear for years that the FDP does not have a plan to build the party in North Florida or to deal with small county issues. The Small County Coalition has not worked for years.

    There is never any analysis of programs or strategies. For example was the vote by mail campaign a positive or negative? How many vote by mail ballots were not counted because of lack of signatures? Would the effort to cure bad mail in ballots have been better spent getting out the vote? How many registered Democrats who vote for Republican candidates voted by mail as a result of the Small County Coalition robo calls? How many small counties do not have a functioning DEC?

  2. I disagree. Saying the words “I take responsibility” is not taking responsibility. Saying “We’re going to deep dive into what happened and who didn’t show up to vote and take corrective measures” is not taking responsibility.

    Taking responsibility includes admitting one has made mistakes, and suffering some negative consequences. It involves personal action on the part of the person. Tant has done none of these, so has not moved at all. Promises are cheap, and are the lifeblood of politicians. Judge the FDP by their actions alone.

  3. I agree with these statements. We are possibly going into a “words without action” phase, which is the reason why I stress that Tant has to move beyond the “I take responsibility” part. But up until then, she wasn’t even doing that. At least it is a step in the right direction, but it is only a step, and a baby step at that.

  4. Response to Paul Still:
    As a long term resident of Miami Dade County and a DEC Member, I can attest that the FDP and House Victory got in the way, interfered, undermined and destroyed whatever chance we had of making advances. We even lost a Hispanic Democratic Congressional race after so much hard work to have elected him the first time.

    Our impression in Miami is that the FDP is North Florida dominated and oriented and does not understand the complexities of the multicultural dynamics of South Florida, Christian Ulvert notwithstanding. Mr. Ulvert selected idiots to support and ignored viable candidates, as the FDP is historically wont to do.

    Miami Dade County was doing great work and making advances until Crist took our chairwoman, Annette Taddeo, away from us. She became almost like an extinct creature in Miami. No signs or banners or yard signs with Annette’s name appeared in her home county. the County Party was rudderless. No wonder we underperformed the 2010 disastrous turnout by one point.

    My suggestion is for the FDP to stay the hell away from us. Keep Debbie Wasserman Schultz and Dan Gelber north of Orlando.

  5. Dave, my position is that words, by themselves is not “moving”. For an obvious example of this, see the book Animal Farm. All criminals express regret at sentencing – most of them continue their pattern of behavior when released. So my point is that words are NOT a “baby step”.

  6. Agreed Dog, the FDP is north Florida dominated, hence the reason the party has been obsessed with Southerland over the last few cycles.

    And Bruce, I totally understand where you are coming from, and I mostly agree. Maybe I am trying to find a silver lining where there isn’t any. Again, we will see what happens now. Unfortunately, it is in places like Highlands County that suffer the most when the FDP’s central apparatus is weak.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s